LAW OFFICE OF ALENA SHAUTSOVA · NEW YORK IMMIGRATION LITIGATION
New York Deportation Defense Lawyer: Your Case Starts With a Strategy
Your family. Your freedom. Your future in the United States. When removal is on the line, every allegation, document, and answer matters.
A Notice to Appear is the beginning of a legal case against you. It is also the point at which your defense needs a plan: what to challenge, what relief to pursue, what evidence to build, and how to protect your rights through trial and appeal.
The Law Office of Alena Shautsova represents people facing deportation in Immigration Court, before the Board of Immigration Appeals, and in appropriate federal court proceedings.
We bring extensive courtroom experience, careful preparation, and persuasive legal writing to cases involving asylum, cancellation of removal, criminal allegations, waivers, prior denials, and existing removal orders.
Paid consultations · English and Russian · Offices in Brooklyn and Amityville, New York
What Does a Deportation Defense Lawyer Do?
A deportation defense lawyer evaluates whether the government can legally remove you, identifies available defenses and immigration benefits, prepares your evidence and testimony, and represents you in hearings and appeals. The goal may be to defeat the charges, preserve permanent residence, obtain protection or a green card, reopen an unfairly decided case, or pursue another lawful resolution.
Our approach is results-oriented: define the legal objective, identify the obstacles, and build the record needed to pursue it.
We explain the strengths, weaknesses, costs, and practical limits of your options so you can make informed decisions.
Courtroom Experience That Shapes Your Defense From Day One
Immigration litigation requires judgment under pressure: when to contest a charge, how to develop testimony, which legal issues need briefing, and what must be preserved for appeal. Attorney Alena Shautsova’s extensive courtroom experience informs each stage of preparation.
Direct examination
We prepare you and your witnesses to explain the facts clearly and truthfully. Questions are developed around the elements the judge must decide, including persecution, hardship, rehabilitation, family relationships, and eligibility for relief.
Cross-examination and redirect
We prepare you for difficult questions from DHS and the judge, address inconsistencies before the hearing, cross-examine government witnesses when appropriate, and use redirect to clarify testimony challenged on cross-examination.
Briefs, motions, and objections
We connect the evidence to the governing statutes and precedent through legal briefs, motions, and oral argument. We challenge unsupported allegations and unreliable evidence where the law permits, and make objections that protect the record.
Appeal preparation
We approach trial with possible review in mind: identify legal issues, develop evidence, make necessary arguments, and preserve objections. An appellate argument is stronger when the underlying record supports it.
Admitted in New York in 2008 and to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in 2016, Alena Shautsova combines years of immigration practice with hands-on litigation experience.
Read Alena Shautsova’s professional background.
A Published Case Example: Challenging an Added Government Charge
In a permanent resident’s cancellation case described on our website, DHS added a drug-trafficking inadmissibility charge. Ms. Shautsova challenged whether that charge applied to a client who was not seeking admission. The court agreed with the argument, DHS withdrew the added charge, and the client continued pursuing cancellation of removal.
This illustrates why defense starts with the government’s legal theory—not only an application for relief.
Read our published case results.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Your Defense Begins With Strategy, NTA Answers, and Preparation
1. Review the Notice to Appear Before Making Admissions
The Notice to Appear, usually Form I-862, lists factual allegations and the government’s charges of removability. We examine your identity, citizenship, entries, immigration status, alleged violations, service history, and the legal basis for each charge.
We then prepare pleadings: which allegations to admit or deny, whether to concede or contest removability, and which objections or motions should be raised. These answers can affect your options. An admission should follow a legal analysis, not a routine assumption that DHS is correct.
A missing date, incorrect allegation, or other NTA issue may matter, but
an NTA defect does not automatically dismiss your case
. Different rules govern notice, claim-processing objections, and cancellation’s stop-time rule. The remedy depends on the defect, timing, procedural history, and controlling law.
2. Identify the Primary Defense and Viable Alternatives
We review the full immigration timeline, prior applications, court records, criminal dispositions, family relationships, and fear of return. We determine whether to contest removability, apply for relief, coordinate a USCIS petition, or pursue several legally compatible options. We also examine statutory bars and issues that could defeat an otherwise promising case.
3. Build the Evidence Before the Deadline
A strong file connects each legal requirement to supporting proof. Depending on the case, that may include certified criminal records, entry documents, tax and employment records, medical evaluations, school services, expert opinions, country conditions, and testimony from people with firsthand knowledge.
We address difficult facts directly: prior inconsistent statements, missing documents, past arrests, travel, previous denials, and discrepancies between testimony and earlier filings. Preparation means truthful, accurate testimony—not memorized or invented answers.
4. Prepare for the Master Calendar and Individual Hearing
At the preliminary stage, the court may address pleadings, applications, scheduling, and deadlines. At an individual merits hearing, the case may involve testimony, exhibits, expert evidence, objections, and legal argument. Some matters can be decided on motions or the written record; not every application necessarily receives a full testimonial hearing.
After the judge rules, we evaluate the decision, appeal rights, potential motions, and whether separate action is needed to prevent removal. A denial requires a prompt, focused response.
Already have a lawyer, but need clarity?
Our second-opinion consultations examine the charges, proposed defenses, evidence gaps, and upcoming deadlines. Bring your NTA, applications, court orders, and any prior attorney submissions.
What Defenses and Relief May Be Available in Immigration Court?
There is no single defense that fits every removal case. The following is a broad screening guide to the principal defenses, forms of relief, and related strategies. Availability depends on your history, the type of proceeding, jurisdiction, statutory bars, and current law.
Defense or strategy
What we evaluate
Contest removability
Whether DHS can establish the allegations and charges under the applicable burden of proof; incorrect status classifications, legally insufficient criminal charges, and other defects.
Citizenship or nationality claims
Whether you acquired or derived U.S. citizenship through a parent or have another valid nationality defense. A U.S. citizen is not subject to removal as a noncitizen.
Termination, dismissal, and evidentiary motions
Legally supported challenges to proceedings or evidence, including suppression in qualifying circumstances. These remedies have demanding requirements and are not automatic.
LPR cancellation of removal
A possible way for qualifying green card holders to retain permanent residence despite removability.
Non-LPR cancellation of removal
A possible path to permanent residence for qualifying people with sufficient physical presence and the required hardship to qualifying family members.
VAWA special-rule cancellation
Relief for certain survivors of battery or extreme cruelty, with separate presence, hardship, character, and eligibility requirements.
Defensive asylum
Persecution or a well-founded fear tied to a protected ground, filing deadlines and exceptions, and applicable eligibility bars.
Statutory withholding of removal
Protection from removal to a country where the applicable threat to life or freedom is more likely than not, subject to statutory bars.
Convention Against Torture protection
Withholding or deferral of removal based on a likelihood of torture involving a public official or official consent or acquiescence. Different bars apply to withholding and deferral.
Adjustment of status
Family, employment, VAWA, or other qualifying bases for a green card, including INA § 245(i) where applicable. Entry history, visa availability, admissibility, and jurisdiction matter.
Waivers
Ground-specific relief, potentially including INA §§ 212(h), 212(i), 237(a)(1)(H), or 209(c), depending on the charge, status, benefit sought, and adjudicator’s authority.
I-751 review
Review of a denial of a petition to remove conditions on residence, including qualifying waiver claims and the applicable burdens in removal proceedings.
Special and legacy relief
NACARA, qualifying former § 212(c) relief, suspension of deportation in appropriate older proceedings, registry, Cuban adjustment, and other narrowly applicable statutory programs.
Voluntary departure
Whether an authorized departure without a removal order is a suitable alternative. Departure deadlines, bonds, waivers of rights, and future inadmissibility must be evaluated.
Related Benefits That May Require USCIS Action
U visas, T visas, VAWA self-petitions, Special Immigrant Juvenile petitions, TPS, and certain other humanitarian benefits may affect a removal strategy, but they are not interchangeable with relief an immigration judge can grant. USCIS generally adjudicates the underlying petitions or status requests; SIJ classification also requires qualifying state-court findings.
A pending petition does not automatically stop proceedings or removal. We evaluate whether a continuance, termination, administrative closure, reopening, or other procedural action is legally available and appropriate. Prosecutorial discretion, deferred action, and a stay request are separate possibilities in qualifying cases; they are discretionary and do not themselves create permanent residence.
The proceeding type matters.
Asylum-only, withholding-only, reinstatement, and expedited removal follow different rules from ordinary INA § 240 proceedings. Some defenses listed above will not be available in those settings.
Which defense fits your case?
The right starting point is a review of your records, not a guess based on how long you have lived here or whether you have a U.S. citizen relative.
Cancellation of Removal: Two Different Paths, Different Proof
Cancellation for Lawful Permanent Residents: Form EOIR-42A
The core statutory requirements generally include at least five years as a lawful permanent resident, seven years of continuous residence after admission in any status, and no aggravated felony conviction. Additional exclusions apply, and approval requires a favorable exercise of discretion.
The seven-year residence calculation requires a careful stop-time analysis, including certain offenses and service of a legally sufficient NTA. The five-year permanent-residence requirement is a separate calculation. Unlike ordinary non-LPR cancellation, LPR cancellation does not require exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying relative.
We examine the precise conviction, dates, admission history, family ties, rehabilitation, and positive equities. A green card does not make someone immune from removal, but a criminal allegation does not answer every question about eligibility.
Cancellation for Nonpermanent Residents: Form EOIR-42B
Ordinary non-LPR cancellation generally requires:
At least ten years of qualifying continuous physical presence, subject to stop-time and departure rules.
Good moral character during the required period.
No disqualifying convictions or other statutory bars.
Exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse, parent, or child.
A favorable exercise of discretion.
Ten years in the United States is not a stand-alone green card program.
Ordinary cancellation is generally sought in removal proceedings. Starting a court case just to pursue cancellation can expose someone to serious risk.
Hardship Must Be Proven With Specific Evidence
The hardship standard exceeds the consequences ordinarily expected from a family’s separation or relocation. We develop the combined impact on qualifying relatives: medical and mental-health needs, disability, education, caregiving, financial dependence, language barriers, and access to treatment and support abroad.
Medical records alone may not explain what removal would mean. A persuasive presentation connects the diagnosis, treatment needs, family circumstances, and likely consequences through documents and credible testimony. A child’s age and immigration-law definition of “child” can also affect the strategy.
Ordinary non-LPR cancellation is subject to an annual statutory limit that can delay final grants. Special-rule VAWA cancellation has different requirements and must be assessed separately.
Asylum, Withholding, and CAT: Prepare the Claim for Litigation
Fear of return must be translated into a legally supported claim. We evaluate the protected ground, persecutor’s motive, government involvement or failure of protection, internal relocation, corroboration, credibility, and country conditions. We prepare declarations, witness testimony, and expert evidence where useful.
Asylum generally has a one-year filing deadline, with recognized exceptions. Withholding and CAT have different standards, consequences, and bars. Withholding or CAT protection does not itself provide a green card, derivative protection for relatives, or an unrestricted right to remain regardless of a possible third-country removal.
We also prepare responses when DHS seeks to deny an application before a full evidentiary hearing.
Criminal Charges, Drug Offenses, and Green Card Holders
A criminal case can affect removability, detention, eligibility for relief, travel, and future immigration benefits. The label used in criminal court—“misdemeanor,” for example—does not determine the immigration result. We analyze the statute, elements, sentence, certified record, and controlling precedent.
Controlled-Substance Offenses Require a Precise Analysis
INA § 237(a)(2)(B)(i) creates a deportability ground for qualifying controlled-substance convictions after admission, with a narrow exception for a single offense involving possession for one’s own use of 30 grams or less of marijuana. That exception does not erase every other immigration consequence or automatically establish admissibility.
We examine whether the statute matches the federal ground and, where legally permitted, what the record of conviction establishes. An unidentified drug in a record is not a universal defense: the categorical framework, divisibility, burden of proof, and relief being sought can change the outcome.
LPR cancellation, narrow waiver provisions, CAT protection, or legally valid post-conviction relief may warrant review, depending on the facts. Many drug grounds have no ordinary waiver.
An expungement or rehabilitation-based dismissal usually does not eliminate an immigration conviction.
A vacatur based on an underlying substantive or procedural defect requires a different analysis. Federal first-offender treatment is narrow and should never be assumed to apply to a state disposition.
If criminal charges are pending, immigration consequences should be reviewed before a plea. Where appropriate, we coordinate with criminal defense counsel about legally available options.
Denied in Court? BIA Appeals, Motions, and Federal Review
Board of Immigration Appeals
A BIA appeal challenges an immigration judge’s decision through focused legal and factual arguments supported by the record. We evaluate credibility findings, the legal standard applied, treatment of evidence, procedural fairness, and other reviewable errors. A brief should explain why the decision cannot stand under the applicable standard of review.
A notice of appeal generally must be received by the BIA within 30 calendar days of the judge’s oral decision or mailing of a written decision. Reserving appeal at the hearing is not a substitute for timely filing. Waiving appeal can have immediate consequences.
Motions to Reopen or Reconsider
Reopening generally asks the court or BIA to consider material new facts or evidence. Reconsideration identifies errors of law or fact in an existing decision. Ordinary deadlines are generally 90 days for reopening and 30 days for reconsideration; numerical limits and exceptions require separate review.
Missed-hearing orders, changed country conditions, certain survivor claims, joint motions, and ineffective-assistance issues may involve different rules. A pending motion usually does not automatically stop removal; any applicable stay must be examined separately.
Federal Court Review and Detention Litigation
Where legally available, a petition for review asks a federal court of appeals to examine a final removal decision. Jurisdiction, exhaustion, filing deadlines, and limits on review must be evaluated promptly. Federal review is generally based on the administrative record, which is one reason trial preparation matters so much.
A petition for review does not automatically stay removal. A separate stay motion may be needed. Detention challenges, including appropriate habeas proceedings, involve a different analysis from a challenge to the removal order itself.
If you already have a decision, contact us with the complete decision and its date.
Do not wait for an enforcement appointment to ask about review.
ICE Detention, Bond, and Existing Removal Orders
When a family member is detained, we assess the detention authority, eligibility for a bond hearing, the court’s jurisdiction, and any available release or federal-court remedies. Some people are subject to mandatory detention or other restrictions, and not every detainee can obtain an immigration judge bond hearing.
Release from detention does not resolve the removal case. A bond strategy and a merits defense serve different purposes and may need to proceed together.
DACA, Administrative Closure, and Reopened Proceedings
DACA is deferred action, not permanent immigration status or a permanent defense to removal. Administrative closure is also different from termination: an administratively closed case may later be placed back on the active docket.
If you receive a motion to recalendar, a new hearing notice, or an NTA, obtain a review of the actual document and your procedural history. The legal effect depends on your circumstances and current court orders and policy; an old policy announcement should not be used to predict what will happen in your case.
What to Bring to Your Deportation Defense Consultation
Bring what you have. If your hearing or deadline is close, contact us while gathering the remaining records.
Your NTA, A-number, hearing notices, scheduling orders, and all immigration decisions.
Passports, I-94s, green cards, work permits, and a timeline of entries and departures.
Previous immigration applications, supporting statements, interview records, and attorney submissions.
Certified dispositions for every arrest or criminal case, including dismissed or sealed matters, when available.
Family members’ status documents and relevant medical, school, financial, or caregiving records.
For detention matters: the person’s full name, A-number, detention location, and available ICE documents.
We assess the procedural posture, potential defenses, evidence gaps, deadlines, and scope of representation. You receive a candid explanation of the available options and a fee quote for the proposed work. Representation begins only after the engagement requirements are completed.
Your Next Court Date Should Have a Plan Behind It.
Whether you just received an NTA, are preparing for trial, need a second opinion, or want to challenge a denial, start with a focused legal assessment.
Can a deportation defense lawyer stop my deportation?
A lawyer may be able to challenge the charges, obtain relief, reopen proceedings, or seek a stay when the law permits. The available options depend on your immigration and criminal history, case stage, and deadlines. No lawyer can guarantee that deportation will be stopped.
Does a Notice to Appear mean I have already been ordered deported?
An NTA generally lists the allegations and charges that DHS wants the Immigration Court to decide. It is not itself a removal order. Prior orders and special removal procedures can change the analysis, so your complete history must be reviewed.
Should I admit the allegations at my first immigration hearing?
Admissions and concessions can affect your defense. An attorney should examine the NTA, underlying records, and applicable law before deciding which allegations to admit or deny and whether to contest removability.
Can I get a green card after living in the United States for ten years?
Ten years alone does not establish eligibility. Ordinary non-LPR cancellation also requires good moral character, no disqualifying bars, exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying relative, and a favorable exercise of discretion. Stop-time and departure rules can prevent eligibility.
Can a green card holder be deported?
Yes. Permanent residents can face removal for certain criminal convictions and other grounds. Depending on the case, defenses may include contesting the charge, LPR cancellation, qualifying waivers, or other legally available relief.
Will marrying a U.S. citizen end my immigration court case?
No. A genuine marriage may support a family petition and possible adjustment strategy, but it does not automatically end proceedings or erase inadmissibility. Entry history, marriage timing, prior findings, visa eligibility, and court or USCIS jurisdiction must be reviewed.
Can I apply for asylum if I am already in Immigration Court?
In appropriate proceedings, you may seek defensive asylum. Filing deadlines, bars, jurisdiction, and the legal sufficiency of the claim matter. Withholding of removal or CAT protection may need separate consideration.
What happens if I miss an immigration hearing?
The judge may issue an in absentia removal order if the legal requirements are met. Reopening may be possible based on lack of required notice, qualifying exceptional circumstances, or other applicable grounds. Different deadlines and proof requirements apply; seek review promptly.
How long does a deportation case take?
There is no reliable universal timeline. Detention, the court docket, proceeding type, motions, evidence needs, and appeals can affect timing. Some matters move quickly, and waiting for a later hearing does not extend an existing filing deadline.
Does an appeal or motion automatically stop deportation?
It depends on the filing and procedural posture. A timely merits appeal to the BIA often carries a regulatory stay, subject to exceptions. Motions to reopen and federal petitions for review generally do not automatically stay removal. Counsel must verify whether a stay applies or must be requested.
Can you take over a case or provide a second opinion?
Yes. We review existing cases, prior denials, and proposed defense strategies. A change of attorney must comply with court rules and does not automatically postpone a hearing or filing deadline.
How much does a deportation defense lawyer cost?
Fees depend on detention, complexity, criminal and immigration history, evidence needs, hearing preparation, and whether appeals or federal litigation are included. Our office offers paid consultations and provides a fee quote for the proposed scope of representation.
Do I still need to attend court after hiring a lawyer?
Yes, unless the court has specifically excused your appearance or changed the hearing requirements. Follow the actual hearing notice and court orders. Hiring counsel, filing an application, or requesting a continuance does not itself excuse attendance.
How do I update my address while my case is in court?
Follow the court’s address-change requirements, usually using Form EOIR-33 for the relevant court or BIA, and serve DHS as required. Updating USCIS alone does not update Immigration Court records. Confirm the applicable deadline and keep proof of submission.